Page MenuHomePhorge

Discussion NeededTag
ActivePublic

Members

  • This project does not have any members.
  • View All

Watchers

  • This project does not have any watchers.
  • View All

Details

Description

Tasks that require more thinking/input from community to reach an decision for the most suitable implementation.

Not to be confused with Clarification Needed - to be used when the general background is unclear or partially Invalid.

Recent Activity

Wed, Dec 11

BlankEclair added a revision to T15972: Add config option for maximum file size: D25853: Add configuration option for maximum file size.
Wed, Dec 11, 07:50 · Discussion Needed, Files
avivey added a comment to T15972: Add config option for maximum file size.

(we can probably keep this ticket open, so that we have the 2nd part on the backlog. I'm pretty sure we want it to happen "eventually".)

Wed, Dec 11, 07:20 · Discussion Needed, Files
valerio.bozzolan added a comment to T15972: Add config option for maximum file size.

Feel free to show something early :) That would attract more attention than the Discussion Needed tag I bet

Wed, Dec 11, 07:13 · Discussion Needed, Files
BlankEclair added a comment to T15972: Add config option for maximum file size.

Wrote the code for the first phase :p

Wed, Dec 11, 07:01 · Discussion Needed, Files
BlankEclair added a comment to T15972: Add config option for maximum file size.

Sounds good to me :p

Wed, Dec 11, 04:32 · Discussion Needed, Files

Mon, Dec 9

valerio.bozzolan added a comment to T15972: Add config option for maximum file size.

We can also ship this feature in two phases, so, first, adding the option files.maximum-file-size, and then the second one when it's ready or requested lol

Mon, Dec 9, 16:03 · Discussion Needed, Files
BlankEclair added a comment to T15972: Add config option for maximum file size.

Yeah, I agree, though I would then only work on implementing files.maximum-file-size because we don't really care that much about adding exceptions to the rule (as far as I know lol)

Mon, Dec 9, 14:16 · Discussion Needed, Files
valerio.bozzolan added a comment to T15972: Add config option for maximum file size.

Uh, that would be so good. So you can say "When the moon is full".

Mon, Dec 9, 08:36 · Discussion Needed, Files
avivey added a comment to T15972: Add config option for maximum file size.

Sounds reasonable.

Mon, Dec 9, 08:12 · Discussion Needed, Files

Sun, Dec 8

valerio.bozzolan added a project to T15972: Add config option for maximum file size: Discussion Needed.

I like your option names. I like to specify PHIDs and not numeric IDs so it's more portable against import/exports 👍 Let's add Discussion Needed to attract some +1 or nice suggestions.

Sun, Dec 8, 18:11 · Discussion Needed, Files

Thu, Nov 28

20after4 updated the task description for T15961: Should we adopt modern PHP type hints in Phorge source code?.
Thu, Nov 28, 03:10 · Phorge Development Tools, Discussion Needed
20after4 created T15961: Should we adopt modern PHP type hints in Phorge source code?.
Thu, Nov 28, 03:10 · Phorge Development Tools, Discussion Needed

Tue, Nov 26

aklapper closed T15916: Conduit maniphest.gettasktransactions: include metadata and title, a subtask of T15081: Figure out if there are patches from Wikimedia's fork that are desirable to upstream in Phorge, as Resolved.
Tue, Nov 26, 13:08 · Discussion Needed, Affects-Wikimedia

Oct 9 2024

20after4 updated subscribers of T15501: Voluntary Usage Survey App.

There is a significant amount of Phabricator dark matter out there - companies/people using the software, it works well enough, not really easy to know they exist or anything about their usage. I'm sure at least some of them have moved to Phorge. Automattic/wordpress.com have moved to Phorge and I wasn't even aware that they were using Phabricator before that. This is despite the fact that I did a pretty extensive amount of research to identify every company using Phabricator back in ~2019 as part of my work for Wikimedia, with the goal of reaching out and trying to organize an informal Phabricator users group. We had the idea that the various corporate users probably had good reasons to be collaborating and at least talking to each other since most of them were not active in the upstream project. Anyway, that never really panned out, although it did trigger a flurry of interest and some ongoing discussions via email (maybe even one video meeting but I can't remember the details now.)

Oct 9 2024, 07:16 · Discussion Needed

Sep 20 2024

valerio.bozzolan closed T15489: Diffusion commit feed: avoid to repeat the commit message twice, a subtask of T15924: Commit feed body: it should probably show (part of) commit body, as Resolved.
Sep 20 2024, 01:58 · Discussion Needed, Diffusion

Sep 6 2024

aklapper closed T15882: When archiving a project, reset its default menu item to Profile as Wontfix.

Abandoning in favor of T15890 and D25774 per previous discussion

Sep 6 2024, 16:58 · Discussion Needed, Feature Requests, Projects

Sep 4 2024

valerio.bozzolan added a parent task for T15938: Understand if Diffusion public identities could be used to expand Calendar invitees: T15939: Calendar Import Invitees 2.0.
Sep 4 2024, 17:59 · Discussion Needed, Calendar
valerio.bozzolan updated the task description for T15938: Understand if Diffusion public identities could be used to expand Calendar invitees.
Sep 4 2024, 17:57 · Discussion Needed, Calendar
valerio.bozzolan created T15938: Understand if Diffusion public identities could be used to expand Calendar invitees.
Sep 4 2024, 17:56 · Discussion Needed, Calendar

Aug 21 2024

valerio.bozzolan added a subtask for T15924: Commit feed body: it should probably show (part of) commit body: T15489: Diffusion commit feed: avoid to repeat the commit message twice.
Aug 21 2024, 18:34 · Discussion Needed, Diffusion
valerio.bozzolan created T15924: Commit feed body: it should probably show (part of) commit body.
Aug 21 2024, 18:33 · Discussion Needed, Diffusion

Aug 14 2024

valerio.bozzolan updated the task description for T15081: Figure out if there are patches from Wikimedia's fork that are desirable to upstream in Phorge.
Aug 14 2024, 16:05 · Discussion Needed, Affects-Wikimedia

Aug 10 2024

omorrigan added a comment to T15501: Voluntary Usage Survey App.

I think that is complex because some admins are not well active on their platforms, so as said before it can be underdimensioned

Aug 10 2024, 14:05 · Discussion Needed

Aug 2 2024

aklapper added a comment to T15100: [Feature request] Option to measure WIP limits based on card count instead of points, to more closely adhere to Kanban standards..

I'm not skilled enough to look into the bigger picture, however maybe the Edit Column dialog could have a third field apart from Name and Point Limit to also have Task Limit (or Card Limit?). Point Limit and Task Limit then must be mutually exclusive (do not allow to set both for a column, or even...board?), somehow.

Aug 2 2024, 10:28 · Feature Requests, Maniphest, Discussion Needed, Affects-Wikimedia, Workboard

Jul 29 2024

valerio.bozzolan closed T15161: Internal resources should avoid to become external links, as default as Resolved by committing rP349f006904fa: Remarkup: make less internal links open in new tabs.
Jul 29 2024, 10:42 · User-valerio.bozzolan, Discussion Needed, Remarkup

Jul 24 2024

valerio.bozzolan created T15892: Post-Commit Audit review: authors cannot "Raise Concern".
Jul 24 2024, 09:27 · Discussion Needed, Bug Reports, Diffusion

Jul 23 2024

valerio.bozzolan added a comment to T15882: When archiving a project, reset its default menu item to Profile.

OK. If you are partially mentioning nonsenses in we.phorge.it itself, you are indeed right.

Jul 23 2024, 08:50 · Discussion Needed, Feature Requests, Projects

Jul 22 2024

aklapper added a comment to T15882: When archiving a project, reset its default menu item to Profile.

We might come from different user journeys.
Your users might be aware what the project means, and that the project (and its workboard) is archived, and they do have an initial reason to look at this archived workboard (e.g. default view is not "open tasks" but "all tasks")?
My users clicked an external link to some project tag in something called Phorge, and that project has been archived in the meantime, and that project is set to show the workboard by default, and that is now just empty columns (as the default view of workboards is "open tasks"), and that is confusing and unhelpful.

Jul 22 2024, 14:17 · Discussion Needed, Feature Requests, Projects

Jul 21 2024

valerio.bozzolan renamed T15670: Diffusion repository commits: avoid to be a black hole for webcrawlers from Diffusion repository commits: avoid to be a black hoile for webcrawlers to Diffusion repository commits: avoid to be a black hole for webcrawlers.
Jul 21 2024, 08:39 · Discussion Needed
valerio.bozzolan renamed T15670: Diffusion repository commits: avoid to be a black hole for webcrawlers from Disallow webcrawlers to index Diffusion repository commits to Diffusion repository commits: avoid to be a black hoile for webcrawlers.
Jul 21 2024, 08:39 · Discussion Needed
valerio.bozzolan added a comment to T15670: Diffusion repository commits: avoid to be a black hole for webcrawlers.

(Trying to make this task a bit more about the root problem, and less about the proposed solution)

Jul 21 2024, 08:39 · Discussion Needed
valerio.bozzolan added a parent task for T15882: When archiving a project, reset its default menu item to Profile: T15886: Archived Projects: make them "more Archived" .
Jul 21 2024, 08:33 · Discussion Needed, Feature Requests, Projects
valerio.bozzolan removed a subtask for T15882: When archiving a project, reset its default menu item to Profile: T15886: Archived Projects: make them "more Archived" .
Jul 21 2024, 08:33 · Discussion Needed, Feature Requests, Projects
valerio.bozzolan added a subtask for T15882: When archiving a project, reset its default menu item to Profile: T15886: Archived Projects: make them "more Archived" .
Jul 21 2024, 08:33 · Discussion Needed, Feature Requests, Projects
valerio.bozzolan added a comment to T15882: When archiving a project, reset its default menu item to Profile.

I mean. See this archived Project (archived Milestone), that is linked from our changelogs:

Jul 21 2024, 08:24 · Discussion Needed, Feature Requests, Projects

Jul 20 2024

aklapper added a comment to T15882: When archiving a project, reset its default menu item to Profile.

For example, some people then may ask "why my default view was changed?" and they will start manually "rollbacking" this to their desired view (e.g. showing closed tasks, from the Workboard, with a filter "Show all tasks").

Jul 20 2024, 09:27 · Discussion Needed, Feature Requests, Projects
valerio.bozzolan added a project to T15882: When archiving a project, reset its default menu item to Profile: Discussion Needed.

Premising that I like the implementation but I think it's not the desired solution.

Jul 20 2024, 08:50 · Discussion Needed, Feature Requests, Projects

Jul 1 2024

valerio.bozzolan updated the task description for T15744: Render html color codes in remarkup.
Jul 1 2024, 07:00 · Discussion Needed, Remarkup
valerio.bozzolan added a comment to T15744: Render html color codes in remarkup.

I think GitHub allows that syntax only in comments 🤔

Jul 1 2024, 06:50 · Discussion Needed, Remarkup
20after4 added a comment to T15744: Render html color codes in remarkup.

I was unaware of `#0969DA` syntax from github/gitlab.

Jul 1 2024, 02:55 · Discussion Needed, Remarkup
20after4 added a comment to T15744: Render html color codes in remarkup.

I was unaware of #0969DA syntax from github/gitlab. I'm not sure if I like that syntax better than {} but I am generally in favor of using the same syntax as other systems in order to converge towards defacto standardization.

Jul 1 2024, 02:46 · Discussion Needed, Remarkup

Jun 30 2024

valerio.bozzolan added a comment to T15744: Render html color codes in remarkup.

Thanks again @20after4 for the efforts.

Jun 30 2024, 13:23 · Discussion Needed, Remarkup
valerio.bozzolan added a project to T15744: Render html color codes in remarkup: Discussion Needed.
Jun 30 2024, 13:14 · Discussion Needed, Remarkup

May 8 2024

avivey added a comment to T15096: Discuss Arcanist as a barrier to adoption of Phorge and how to address the underlying issues..

Another problem dramatically frequent for newcomers (at least in my office).

It's relatively too much easy to start with a similar commit message:
...

May 8 2024, 08:25 · Discussion Needed, Arcanist

May 7 2024

valerio.bozzolan added a comment to T15096: Discuss Arcanist as a barrier to adoption of Phorge and how to address the underlying issues..

At least, please go to GitLab, instead of GitHub, so at least you use Free Software :)

May 7 2024, 09:08 · Discussion Needed, Arcanist
micax added a comment to T15096: Discuss Arcanist as a barrier to adoption of Phorge and how to address the underlying issues..

Just some (probably final) thoughts on arcanist and phabricator/phorge. After quite a bit of discussion internally, we are moving on to GitHub with our repositories (which were previously stored in another Git server - not Phabricator). But that move also spells the end for our/my 10+ year long use of Phabricator, because when we move to GitHub, we'll also be ditching Phabricator for code reviews.

May 7 2024, 07:58 · Discussion Needed, Arcanist

Apr 25 2024

Iniquity added a comment to T15082: Consider allowing milestone columns to be ordered arbitrarily on workboards.

It seems to me that this problem can be solved with an additional setting that turns this functionality on or off.

Apr 25 2024, 19:10 · Discussion Needed, Affects-Wikimedia, Workboard

Apr 24 2024

avivey moved T15231: Maybe make automatic workboard display sub-projects as columns? from Backlog to Discussion Needed on the Workboard board.
Apr 24 2024, 06:25 · Discussion Needed, Workboard

Apr 11 2024

revi added a comment to T15670: Diffusion repository commits: avoid to be a black hole for webcrawlers.

Probably my somewhat 10 cents at a broader level;

Apr 11 2024, 17:58 · Discussion Needed

Apr 4 2024

avivey added a comment to T15670: Diffusion repository commits: avoid to be a black hole for webcrawlers.

We don't create the links to page$line in most places as hrefs, so this shouldn't be an issue.

  • Don't exist in Diffusion
  • Do exist in Paste
  • Don't exist in Differential
Apr 4 2024, 21:34 · Discussion Needed