Uh interesting - good to know for the future. So at least the button Mark All Read here in F3271029 should be visible for your case - as very minimal mitigation sub-task

The mark all read link in the notifications dropdown panel is always available. (It did clear the phantom notification.)

The current workaround is to wait for a real notification, to then finally be able to click the Mark All Read.

It happened to me but only in Wikimedia Phabricator, there I had a notification counter in the top-bar, but with no unread messages in the related list

I don't understand the problem described...

Search brings up rP70d67a3908b8: Fix the most significant "phantom notification" badness

P.S. - useful snippet shared by Daimona from Wikimedia:

Increasing a bit the priority since this is feasible, simple to reproduce, and really frustrating in 2025.

@Cigaryno: That only works in Phorge itself. See:

as rich text and/or in common markup formats

@Tgr you want something like this?: T16008: Provide an easy way to link to a Phorge task in a user-friendly way
If so, just enclose the task ID in {} (ie {T16008}

(Downstream task: https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T388243 )

There is no Edit Task option in the Add Action... dropdown. What makes you think so?

I can't see an Edit Task option in the dropdown. What actually enables this?

@valerio.bozzolan: Would you like to give this a (hopefully) final review? TIA!

Yeah that makes sense, thanks!

In T15100#18699, @aklapper wrote:

I'm not skilled enough to look into the bigger picture, however maybe the Edit Column dialog could have a third field apart from Name and Point Limit to also have Task Limit (or Card Limit?). Point Limit and Task Limit then must be mutually exclusive (do not allow to set both for a column, or even...board?), somehow.

I think that, after the hidden comment is loaded in its bulk, "some more comments" are loaded as context for the hidden comment 🤔 So I guess that extra loading is probably a feature and not a bug.

The email body says Herald added a comment.
The email subject line header says [Changed Project Column] (not [Commented On]).
So I wouldn't say it is incorrectly attributed.
AFAIK there are no Herald rules which trigger a separate email notification on its own (but I agree that the described behavior also has confused me in the past) as Herald rules are always triggered by some other previous action.

Uh! Out of curiosity, what does the notification look like in your web notifications?

The hacky solution would be to duplicate the current diff block, and then hide the green text on one side and the red text on the other side.